Walter Carpenter: Vermont’s well being care — your cash or your life 

This commentary is by Walter Carpenter of Montpelier, who works in Vermont’s tourism enterprise and is a author and a well being care activist. In 2006, he practically died by the hands of the well being care system and has been an activist since that point, combating for well being care as a public good. He’s on the advisory committee of the Inexperienced Mountain Care Board. 

These days there have been quite a few commentaries in regards to the illness of our well being care system. Invoice Schubart, Julie Wasserman, Mark Hage, Dr. Paul Manganiello and, most just lately, Lee Russ, have all written eloquently and knowledgeably at VTDigger.org about our expensive and lethal well being care dysfunction and provided concepts on the way to probably treatment it — that’s, after all, if we’ve the ethical, social, and particularly the political braveness to do it. 

To date, we’ve not had that braveness. That is evident within the continued struggling below our well being care system (it’s beneficiant to name our well being care mayhem a system, however I’ll keep on with that phrase for now for the sake of brevity and readability) that causes a lot pointless agony. 

Absent from most well being care discourse is the affected person’s view. It’s simple to get misplaced within the swamps of health-care-nerd land, wallowing round in phrases like “all-payer mannequin,” “value-based care,” and hundreds of others that make folks’s eyes glaze over. 

This all conceals what this dysfunctional well being care means for extraordinary folks. As an activist for single-payer well being look after the final dozen or so years, I’ve been carpet bombed with an unknown tonnage of acronyms, charts, graphs, percents, and greater than sufficient knowledge to succeed in to the moon and again.

None of this has a single import on the expertise of being contained in the system for which we pay a lot and get so little in return. A system that’s alleged to look after us after we want it too typically seems like it’s victimizing us for its personal benefit. Take a second, for instance, to learn what medical debt means to the lives of many Vermonters on the web site Medical Debt in Vermont.

In my lengthy years of well being care activism, I’ve heard our administration, our Legislature, and the “specialists” all seek advice from sufferers as “customers.” This turns me pale with suppressed fury. Somebody yellow with jaundice and turning ashen grey due to it, as I used to be 16 years in the past, isn’t a “shopper” selecting to purchase a $10,000 iPhone.

We now have turned our well being care right into a enterprise relationship the place well being care is only a product the patron is shopping for from a system promoting it for the very best worth that it will possibly get for it. 

Lee Russ stated it finest in his Digger commentary, “How many inactions does it take to make a disaster?“: “Well being care quantities to an enormous financial pie. The general public provides the components: cash within the type of insurance coverage premiums, co-pays, deductibles, taxes and the price of companies not lined by insurance coverage. The well being care trade feasts on the pie.” 

This was true even earlier than the doubtful creation of OneCare. When my liver was shutting down and poisoning me 16 years in the past — a situation that would have been fastened in quarter-hour, however dragged on for months due to our insurance coverage system — I used to be requested for my insurance coverage card as typically as I used to be requested how I used to be feeling. I used to be forgotten in physician’s places of work, hospital ready rooms, and surgical procedure prep rooms as if I used to be not there in any respect. I shortly realized that, within the jaws of this machine, if I didn’t combat for myself I won’t survive it.

This was often not the fault of the ground workers, who themselves are handled as uncooked materials for use for revenue, whereas the numerous layers of administration and plethora of administration are thought-about belongings. I at all times admire how underpaid and overworked ground workers handle to deal with scores of sufferers like me being rammed by the system like we have been on a surgical procedure geared to producing ever extra accounts receivable. One totally exhausted nurse fell asleep on my arm as she was sticking the needle of an intravenous tube into me. 

These workers individuals are the human face representing what our well being care ought to and could be if it have been a public good as a substitute of an trade feeding off customers and human “assets.” It’s the physician who took a number of hours from a badly wanted time without work to return into the workplace, coordinate the retrieval of scan outcomes, and personally name me to announce with reduction that I didn’t have bone most cancers, a risk raised by preliminary exams. 

My most up-to-date well being care expertise nonetheless handled me as a “shopper.” A request for my Medicare and Medicare complement playing cards for “billing functions” was the primary query I obtained on the check-in desk of a Vermont hospital on a latest go to for a take a look at. 

It was nearly like a lodge wanting a bank card to safe the reservation. That is extremely dehumanizing. It reduces well being care nearly to a skit by a well-known comic within the final century, Jack Benny, who was requested by a robber throughout a mock holdup, “Your cash or your life.”

Ship us your ideas

VTDigger is now accepting letters to the editor. For details about our tips, and entry to the letter kind, please click here.

 

Current Tales