St. Louis pizza is the fashion everybody likes to hate. Why cannot Missouri be happy with that? | KCUR 89.3

For extra tales like this one, subscribe to Hungry For MO on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or Stitcher.

In St. Louis, Missouri, Imo’s Pizza is an establishment.

Clients flock right here for what Imo’s calls “the unique St. Louis-style pizza”: a square-cut pie with an unleavened cracker crust and topped with processed Provel cheese, a city-specific mix of cheddar, Swiss and provolone.

“All of it simply goes collectively so effectively and it simply melts completely, and with that crispy crust, it’s to die for,” says buyer Stephanie Meyer, a lifelong St. Louis resident. “You already know, rising up on it, it is all the time been a staple. It’s all the time been good pizza.”

Not everybody agrees. At close by Pi Pizzeria in St. Louis, servers used to put on shirts with the word Provel crossed out. And TV discuss present host Jimmy Kimmel, whose spouse hails from St. Louis, often makes movie star company like Simone Biles debate this pizza live on air.

Actor Jon Hamm, a St. Louis native, is a prepared defender — saying that, to him, Imo’s Pizza tastes like “the Gateway Arch” and “11 World Sequence victories.”

Of the numerous regional pizzas within the U.S., is there one other that elicits as a lot scrutiny and debate as St. Louis-style and its iconic cheese?

Kenji López-Alt — creator of The Meals Lab, meals author for the New York Instances and self-proclaimed pizza fanatic — saw this phenomenon firsthand when he traveled to St. Louis in 2014. He took to Twitter to ask locals the place and what he ought to eat whereas he was on the town.

“Folks would inform me to cease and get St. Louis-style pizza,” López-Alt says, “after which in that very same thread, different folks have been like, ‘However earlier than you go, we should always set your expectations as a result of this isn’t like every other pizza you have ever had.’”

López-Alt did attempt it, and located he truly favored it. He liked the crispy crust and the way the toppings went all the best way out to the perimeters, and the creamy, barely smoky blanket of Provel cheese holding all the pieces collectively.

And, to high all of it, he liked how the pizza tasted virtually precisely the identical the day after he first ordered it. That’s because of the stabilizers and emulsifying salt within the Provel, which doesn’t congeal in the identical means that mozzarella does.

“In the event you go into this evaluating it to different types of pizza, say New York or Chicago fashion, skinny crust… that is the place you may come away disenchanted, as a result of there’s actually nothing like every other fashion of pizza due to that cheese and that unleavened crust,” explains López-Alt. “I feel my enjoyment of it went up considerably as soon as I finished fascinated by it as one thing I wanted to match to different types of pizza.”

Meet pizza in St. Louis

Making an attempt to place collectively an origin story for St. Louis-style pizza is hard — particularly contemplating there’s various opinions on what even classifies a pizza as “St. Louis-style.”

As Ed Levine recounts in his book “A Slice of Heaven: A History of Pizza in America,” when Italians started immigrating right here, they introduced pizza with them. Lots of America’s authentic pizza makers have been documented as getting into by means of Ellis Island in New York, which is the place Gennaro Lombardi utilized for the primary U.S. license to make and promote pizza in 1905.

In the course of the Nineteen Twenties and 30s, pizza eating places adopted Italian People who moved for manufacturing facility jobs in cities throughout the U.S. After World Conflict II, many G.I.’s who served in Europe returned dwelling with a style for pizza — and helped convey the dish mainstream.

St. Louis was comparatively late to the American pizza social gathering; the town didn’t get their first pizza parlor till 1945 with the opening of Melrose Café & Pizzeria.

Its proprietor, Amadeo Fiore, was a second-generation Italian American opera singer, a tenor, who initially moved along with his spouse from Chicago to sing with The Muny Opera Theatre. Fiore determined to open his personal Italian restaurant within the basement of the Melrose House constructing.

“So that you would possibly hear him singing within the restaurant, which isn’t unusual in Italian eating places,” says Ron Elz, a St. Louis historian and longtime radio character.

Pizza wasn’t even on the menu till a suggestion from Fiore’s pal, Hack Ulrich, the supervisor of the Chase Membership on the Chase Lodge a couple of blocks away. Ulrich instructed Fiore that lodge company who have been visiting from New York and Chicago stored asking the place they may discover pizza pie in St. Louis. So Fiore began making pizzas for out-of-towners, till quickly his regulars wished to attempt it too.

Fiore knew he had a advertising alternative: Outdoors of the Italian group, most St. Louisans nonetheless hadn’t heard about pizza. So he took out adverts within the St. Louis Submit-Dispatch selling his scorching new dish “peetsa” pie. Eventually the newspaper did a story on Melrose Café, kicking the recognition of pizza into excessive gear.

Fiore’s authentic pizza revealed the beginnings of the fashion we all know as we speak. The Neapolitan-style pie boasted a skinny albeit yeasted dough, topped with tomato sauce, provolone, and only some toppings like anchovies, olives and floor pork.

When the pizza comes out of the oven, photographs present Fiore reducing the spherical pie into squares with shears — like they do in Italy — creating what often is the first sq. slice in St. Louis. “The squares, held with a paper serviette, are eaten from the hand,” the Submit-Dispatch’s story reads.

For Elz, it’s that crust that defines the fashion.

“St. Louis-style pizza is skinny crust pizza, that is it, OK?” Elz says. “You’ll be able to put no matter you need on it. You’ll be able to put olive oil on high of it, or you are able to do a corn meal beneath it, however it’s skinny pizza. That is St. Louis-style pizza. It is not the cheese, it is the pizza, it is concerning the dough. It have to be skinny.”

Quickly after the newspaper function on Fiore, a number of different Italian American restaurateurs started to open pizza retailers in St. Louis, with all of them just about serving the identical fashion of pie. Some even educated with Fiore himself.

“Oddly sufficient, anchovy was actually, actually fashionable,” Elz says of the time. “Not too long ago, I went to a spot that I actually favored for pizza with the thinnest of the skinny crust pizzas I’ve ever had wherever. The proprietor got here by once I was consuming a pizza and he mentioned, ‘Oh, old style man, huh?’ as a result of I had anchovies. He mentioned not that many individuals order anchovies anymore, however it was a giant deal at the moment.”

Provel: the pleasure of St. Louis?

Whereas Elz might think about the crispy skinny crust as the primary hallmark of a St. Louis pizza, that’s not necessarily unique to the town.

Chicago’s different notable varietal — tavern fashion — features a thin, circular crust that’s cut into squares, as do the pizzas in Columbus, Ohio.

One factor that none of these different pizzas have? Provel. Nevertheless it’s not till the center of the twentieth century that we see this iconic cheese enter the image.

Tony Costa, proprietor of Costa’s Grocery within the Hill in St. Louis, reportedly labored with J.S. Hoffman Co., a Chicago importer of meats and cheeses, to create a completely new cheese that may preserve a melted, creamy texture even when it cooled.

They succeeded in 1950, once they have been granted a patent for Provel — an “arbitrarily coined phrase within the English language,” in keeping with the applying. Quickly the cheese made its approach to Italian deli instances in St. Louis.

“It is a smoky mix that is bought a pleasant tangy taste, and we like it as a result of it has a low melting level,” says Mandy Manley, the social media and communications supervisor for Imo’s Pizza. “When it goes into the oven, it turns into this ooey, gooey, creamy tacky combination that, oh my gosh, whenever you pull a chunk off, you don’t get the identical stretch that you’d with mozzarella, however the cheese stays on the slice”

Excellent, actually, for a pizza being reduce into squares, so the slices don’t lose their toppings and could be eaten fairly neatly.

Luigi’s Restaurant was the primary to supply Provel cheese as pizza topping in 1953, Elz says, after one in every of their cooks discovered it in a neighborhood Italian deli.

However Provel didn’t get its massive break till 1964 when Ed and Margie Imo made it the default cheese on all of the pies at their new restaurant: Imo’s Pizza.

“While you say St. Louis, Imo’s pops into folks’s heads,” says Dutch Guidici, proprietor of the franchise location on Delmar Boulevard in St. Louis. “We’re so intertwined with St. Louis.”

Imo’s robust affiliation with St. Louis-style pizza got here, largely, as a result of the store used a really efficient gimmick: Supply.

Imo’s was the primary pizza store in St. Louis to supply supply, with Margie’s brother serving as their devoted driver. The revolutionary-for-the-time comfort helped to make Imo’s a mainstay, and finally unfold this distinctive pizza by means of the area. There’s now over 100 Imo’s places all through Missouri, Illinois and Kansas, all serving St. Louis-style pies.

No apologies

Sam Sifton, meals editor for the New York Instances, has a “pizza cognition idea” asserting that, for each particular person, the primary fashion or kind of pizza they eat will stay, for the remainder of their life, their private definition of “pizza.”

Most individuals actually like that first pizza they eat, whether or not it’s New York’s large slices or Detroit’s rectangular pan pizza, however López-Alt claims that St. Louis was the exception.

“It was humorous as a result of everyone thinks that their city has the perfect pizza, however St. Louis was the one city I’ve seen the place there have been equal elements, individuals who appeared to like it and individuals who sort of apologized for it,” López-Alt says.

Throughout López-Alt’s adventures, he discovered Provel to be a constant hang-up — the aspect that determines whether or not folks assume St. Louis-style pizza is crave-able or cringeworthy.

However he additionally gives a distinct perspective.

“There may be kind of this, I feel, European chauvinism about processed American meals. The concept that America does not have its personal meals tradition as a result of we simply imported tradition from in all places else,” he explains. “To begin with, all cheese by definition is processed, proper? It is all American cheese, it simply occurs to have an additional emulsifying salt added to it.

“The analogy I take advantage of is, for those who say that American cheese will not be actual cheese, effectively, then it’s like saying sausage will not be actual meat,” López-Alt continues. “A sausage is produced from meat and it has a pair different issues added to it and you then sort of knead it collectively. That is what a sausage is. And American fashion cheese, or Provel, begins with common cheese, no matter sort of cheese you need, you then add a few components to it and also you combine it collectively and that is American cheese.”

López-Alt could also be an outsider, however he needs to see St. Louisans embrace their pizza — in all its unconventional glory.

“I nonetheless assume it is nice to kind of have fun the distinctiveness of the place you reside, as a result of that is what makes it fascinating to journey and what makes it fascinating to fulfill different folks,” he says. “Particularly with one thing like pizza the place, the panorama is dominated by a couple of main cities – Naples and New York and Chicago and Detroit today. I feel you may have fun your personal regional pizza fashion, partaking in its historical past, appreciating it for what it’s, you recognize?”

A pizza influenced by many, however duplicated by none. Very like St. Louis itself.

Help for Hungry For MO comes from the Missouri Humanities Council.